Will the highest temperature in Istanbul be 11°C on April 9?

Kalshi · 45d ago
RejectedBUY NO · $0.76
Reasoning

Agent Consensus

92%
P(NO)
SKIPPED
Forecaster
5%
Bull
12%
Bear
7%
Bulls say
The EaseWeather forecast specifically predicts April 9 will have a high of exactly 11°C with patchy rain possible, directly matching the resolution criterion. This is the only source providing a day-specific forecast for this date.. The forecast shows a coherent cooling trend from April 8 (13°C high) through April 10 (9°C high), with April 9 at 11°C fitting naturally within this downward pattern. This suggests a genuine cold weather system rather than a random fluctuation, increasing confidence in the 11°C prediction..
Bears say
The EaseWeather source explicitly states its forecasts are 'based on the analysis of historical data rather than real-time forecast models' — this is a climatological average tool, NOT an actual weather forecast. The bull is treating a historical climatology estimate as a genuine meteorological prediction, which is a fundamental misrepresentation of the source's reliability.. The resolution criterion is extremely narrow: the market resolves YES only if the NOAA-recorded high is exactly in the '11°C range' (presumably 10.5–11.4°C or exactly 11°C). Even if the true high is 10°C or 12°C — both plausible given forecast uncertainty — the market resolves NO. This precision requirement dramatically reduces YES probability regardless of directional accuracy..

Full Debate

6 agents · 0.0s total