Will Tesla (TSLA) beat quarterly earnings?

Polymarket · 31d ago
RejectedREJECTED NO · $0.00
Reasoning

Agent Consensus

77%
P(NO)
SKIPPED
Forecaster
22%
Bull
33%
Bear
14%
Bulls say
The market resolution threshold is $0.39 non-GAAP EPS, but Tesla's own investor relations communication (April 17, 2026) compiled consensus from 20 sell-side analysts at $0.33 adjusted non-GAAP — meaning analysts collectively expect roughly $0.33, and Tesla only needs to hit the analyst midpoint plus modest upside to clear $0.39. Multiple analyst aggregators show consensus in the $0.33-$0.40 range, so $0.39 sits near the high end of plausible outcomes but not unreachable.. Favorable year-over-year comparison base: Q1 2025 adjusted EPS was just $0.27, depressed by the Model Y production changeover. Analysts project 30-48% YoY EPS growth, which puts the plausible outcome range at $0.35-$0.40, straddling the $0.39 threshold. Revenue estimates of $21.4-$23.06B (10-19% YoY growth) support this range..
Bears say
The bull's core framing is misaligned with the actual contract. This market resolves YES only if Tesla reports non-GAAP EPS greater than $0.39, not if it beats Tesla IR's cited analyst consensus of $0.33. A claim that '$0.33 consensus means modest upside can clear $0.39' is mathematically weak: moving from $0.33 to >$0.39 requires more than 18% upside versus that benchmark, which is not 'modest' for a mature large-cap with tightly watched estimates one day before print.. The bull leans on a favorable YoY base from Q1 2025, but low prior-year EPS does not mechanically produce a beat against an absolute threshold. The contract is not 'grow YoY'; it is 'print >$0.39.' If the plausible range is really $0.35-$0.40 as the research itself states, then $0.39 is at the extreme upper tail of that range, not the center. A threshold set at the top end of consensus ranges should imply a low beat probability by construction..

Full Debate

6 agents · 0.0s total